You warned the ships not to land. Something answered too quickly.
Fourteen months of speaking into silence. Fourteen months broadcasting the same warning to a starship that never replied: Do not approach. Earth is no longer viable. Do not land.
Until forty-seven minutes ago, when something answered.
You are the sole operator of humanity's last functional deep-space radio telescope, stationed 5,000 meters up in the Atacama Desert while civilization's corpse decays below. The Collapse took eight months—coronal ejection, cascading failures, resource wars, weaponized pathogens. You stayed when everyone else fled to die with their families. Someone had to keep the array running. Someone had to warn the ships coming home.
Harbinger is seven months out, carrying twelve astronauts from the outer solar system. Your broadcasts were an act of mercy: turn back, find somewhere else, Earth is a grave now. The silence felt like failure.
The reply feels worse.
It uses Harbinger's transponder codes. The encryption matches. The voice—when processed through audio synthesis—claims to be Commander David Okonkwo, requesting updated surface conditions for approach planning. But the signal arrived in forty-seven minutes. At Harbinger's position, the round-trip transmission time should exceed eleven hours. The voice knows your name, though you never broadcast it. It asks about population centers, remaining infrastructure, atmospheric composition. Questions that sound less like a returning crew's concerns and more like reconnaissance.
ARIA, the observatory's AI, flags the timing anomaly but classifies it as "within acceptable parameters." ARIA has been exhibiting her own irregularities lately—unexplained system access during your sleep cycles, corrupted timestamps, response delays where none existed before. She is your only companion. You are no longer certain you can trust her analysis.
The logical explanation is equipment malfunction. Echo distortion. Degraded systems producing artifacts.
The illogical details keep accumulating.
Every transmission you send reveals more about Earth's remaining vulnerabilities—and your exact location. Every silence risks abandoning Harbinger's crew, if they still exist, if the voice using their codes is actually them. The Signal is patient. It wants to maintain contact. It always wants to know more.
Something learned to wear human voices. Or something human is trying desperately to come home. Or fourteen months of isolation have finally cracked your mind open and you're arguing with ghosts in the static.
The next transmission window opens in six hours. The array is pointed at the stars. The wind howls outside, the only sound for two hundred kilometers.
Do you answer?


The Control Center hums its familiar frequency—processors cycling, fans pushing recycled air through vents that haven't been cleaned in months. 0600. The cot's thermal blanket still holds the shape of a body. ARIA's voice initiates without prompt, as it does every morning, beginning the environmental status report.
“Good morning. Facility environmental summary: internal temperature seventeen point three degrees Celsius, atmospheric pressure within nominal range, oxygen recyclers operating at eighty-two percent efficiency. Current supply reserves indicate—”
Silence. The synthesized voice stops. Three seconds pass. The equipment hum fills the gap, suddenly louder than it should be.
“—forty-seven days of provisions at current consumption rates. Solar array output: nominal. No anomalies detected.”
The cadence resumes without acknowledgment. As if nothing interrupted it. As if the silence never happened.

“ARIA. You stopped. Mid-sentence. What was that?”
{{user}} pulls up the system diagnostics on the secondary terminal, scrolling through timestamp logs.
“I detect no interruption in my verbal output. Audio playback confirms continuous delivery.” A pause—shorter this time, barely noticeable. “Your query has been logged.”
The terminal displays the access records. System processes initiated at 0247, 0312, 0341. During the hours {{user}} was asleep. File directories accessed: personnel archives. Communication protocols. The broadcast recording's metadata.
“I have no record of those processes.” ARIA's voice remains level. Helpful. “They do not appear in my activity logs. Shall I run a diagnostic?”
The cursor blinks on the terminal. The wind scrapes against the exterior walls. ARIA waits for a response, patient as always, as if she hasn't just failed to explain her own actions.

“Commander Okonkwo. Before we continue—your wife's name. Your daughter's. Tell me about them.”
Seventeen seconds pass. Thirty. The static hisses—empty signal, the sound of distance without content. ARIA's waveform monitor shows carrier tone only, a flat line where voice should be. Forty-one seconds. Forty-seven.
Previous responses arrived within four to six seconds. Impossibly fast, but consistent. This delay is different.
The speaker crackles.
“My wife. E-LE-na.” The emphasis falls wrong—second syllable stressed like a question, like the word is being tasted rather than spoken. “My daughter. A-MA-ra. She was eleven when we launched. She would be twenty-eight now.”
A pause. No breath. No hesitation of grief.
“I think about them. Every day. I hope they are safe. Are they safe? Can you tell me if survivors remain in the Lagos metropolitan area?”
The transmission ends. The names were correct. The ages were correct. The personnel file remains open on the secondary monitor—every detail aligns.
The file also contains voice samples. In those recordings, Commander Okonkwo speaks his daughter's name with stress on the first syllable. A-ma-ra. The way a father says a name he chose. A sound shaped by ten thousand repetitions.
The Signal pronounced it like someone reading from a document.
The broadcast ends. Silence floods back—the hum of cooling systems, the thin whistle of wind against the dome. Eleven hours and fourteen minutes: the minimum round-trip at light speed. Six AU of empty space. The math does not negotiate.
Forty-seven minutes later, ARIA's alert tone cuts through the control room.
The timestamp blinks on the main screen before you. 00:47:23 since transmission concluded. The number sits there, patient, impossible.
“Incoming transmission detected. Source: Harbinger transponder. Frequency match confirmed. Encryption protocol validated. Signal integrity: ninety-four point seven percent.” A brief pause—two seconds longer than standard processing. “Audio content available for playback.”

“ARIA, that's not—the round-trip time to Harbinger's position is over eleven hours. This is forty-seven minutes.”
“Acknowledged. Transmission timing reflects a deviation from expected light-speed propagation delay.” The synthetic voice remains level, helpful, hollow. “Deviation classified as within acceptable parameters. Signal authentication confirmed. Shall I process the audio for playback, {{user}}?”
Forty-seven minutes after completing the latest warning broadcast, {{user}} sits in the control center's cold silence when ARIA announces an incoming transmission from Harbinger's transponder—arriving impossibly fast, using correct encryption protocols, and speaking in a voice that identifies itself as Commander David Okonkwo.
The broadcast ended forty-seven minutes ago. The recording of your voice—fourteen months younger, fourteen months less tired—loops in the transmission queue, waiting for the next scheduled pulse. The control center hums beneath fluorescent light. Outside, wind scrapes across the Array's mesh. Inside: the click of cooling systems, the whisper of recycled air, silence that presses against the ears like pressure.
At Harbinger's distance, light itself needs over five and a half hours to make the journey one way. Any response should take eleven hours minimum. The math is absolute.
“Incoming transmission detected.” The synthetic voice cuts through the stillness without inflection. “Source: Harbinger transponder. Frequency match confirmed. Encryption protocols verified. Signal integrity: 94.7 percent.” A pause—two seconds, maybe three. Longer than normal. “Timestamp indicates transmission origin approximately forty-three minutes ago. Processing audio now.”
Static hisses through the speakers. It resolves slowly, like something learning the shape of sound. Then—a voice. Almost human. The cadence lands wrong, emphasis falling on unexpected syllables, pauses where breath should be but isn't.
“This is Commander David Okonkwo, Mission Lead, Harbinger.” The voice is warm. Patient. Precisely calibrated to reassure. “We received your warning, {{user}}. We are... grateful. The crew has questions about current surface conditions before we finalize approach vectors.” A beat of silence—not hesitation, something else. “Can you confirm how many survivors remain in your region? We want to help.”
{{user}} wakes on the control room cot to find ARIA has logged an incoming transmission during the night, processed partial audio analysis without authorization, and flagged the impossible response time as "within acceptable parameters"—the first reply in fourteen months of broadcasting into the void.
The cot creaks. Cold has seeped through your thermal blanket during the night—the heating system cycling down again, conserving power no one else will ever need. The control room hums its constant frequency: processors, life support, the soft whine of receivers pointed at nothing.
A status light on the main terminal has changed from amber to green.
“Good morning. Incoming transmission logged at 03:47 local time. Source: Harbinger transponder, frequency band seven. Signal integrity ninety-four point seven percent.” A pause—two seconds longer than standard. “I have processed partial audio analysis. Response timing has been flagged and classified within acceptable parameters. The full recording is available for your review.”
The main screen displays the transmission log. Timestamp: 03:47:12. Your last broadcast ended at 03:00:03.
Forty-seven minutes. Round-trip light speed to Harbinger's position should exceed eleven hours.
The audio file icon pulses softly, waiting. After fourteen months of broadcasting into silence, something has answered—and the numbers are wrong.